Angelo’s Coal Oven Pizzeria: NYC’s Timeless Classic
Discover why Angelo’s Old School Round is a Midtown favorite. Learn what makes coal-oven pizza unique, how Angelo’s crust and sauce stand out, and how this NYC icon evolved since the 1930s.
Where does Angelo’s rank on your NYC pizza shortlist?
If you’re in the NYC metro area and craving authentic pizza, Angelo’s Coal Oven Pizzeria is a must-visit. Their Old School Round earns rave reviews (8.7–9.3), praised for its crisp base, smoky char, and chewy texture—though some note the crust leans hearty.
What Makes Coal-Oven Pizza Unique?
Coal ovens burn anthracite at 900–1,000°F, creating ultra-dry, consistent heat for blistered crusts and caramelized flavors you won’t find in wood or gas-fired pies.
Angelo’s Crust: Unique & Compared
Thin yet substantial, crisp underneath, airy inside, and bagel-like chew—Angelo’s crust is a signature NYC experience.
🍅 Sauce & Salad Pairing
The sauce? Fresh, balanced, and slightly sweet—tying the pie together without overpowering. Pair it with their Caesar salad for a bright, crunchy contrast that complements the smoky richness.
📍 Locations:
117 W 57th St (Midtown)
1697 Broadway (Hell’s Kitchen/Theater District)
👤 Founder & Evolution
Started by Angelo in the late 1930s, this family-run spot has grown from a single shop to a multi-location staple—preserving coal-fired authenticity while expanding menus and spaces.
Question:
#NYCEats #CoalOvenPizza #MidtownDining #NYCFoodies
